(Note: The "team" on which I've placed them does not necessarily indicate their allegiance, simply their most current physical location under the command of one or the other.)
Character | On Island | Flash Sideways |
Jack | Team Jacob | Has son; overcame daddy issues; happy |
Sawyer | Team MIB | Alone; parents still dead; unhappy |
Hurley | Team Jacob | Still rich; lucky/successful; happy |
Sayid | Team MIB | Still a killer; still not with Nadia; unhappy |
Ben | Team Jacob | A teacher; caring; didn't kill dad; happy |
Kate | Team MIB | Still on the run; still alone; unhappy |
Claire | Team MIB | Still preggers w/o dad; still stood up by adoptees; unhappy |
Sun | Team Jacob | Still with Jin; not leaving him; happy? |
Jin | Team MIB | Still working for Mr. Paik; locked in freezer; unhappy? |
Of course, omitted from this table are Locke, Charlie, Daniel and everyone else who is dead on-island (it's difficult to determine their state of happiness); as well as the Wildcard, Desmond.
On island, he was for nearly his entire episode under the control of Team Jacob, via Widmore; but at the end, he apparently was kidnapped by Sayid, so his status is a little unclear. Further, off-island, for most of the episode, he would have fallen under the category of "happy," but appears to be the first of the remaining players to realize that such sideways happiness may not be true.
But even if this apparent parallel indicated something about the relationship between on- and off-island (alternate) happiness, what is it? Those under MIB's control seem to be unhappy off-island. Those under Team Jacob appear to be happy, but that happiness appears to be truly empty. I guess nobody wins in the flash sideways.
Thoughts as to how this might shape an exodus from the flash sideways back to the island? Some other related or unrelated theory? Please share in the comments section.